“a far, far better thing that I do”
Out Stealing Horses“a far, far better thing that I do” is the climactic phrase Trond encounters in the final pages of A Tale of Two Cities. Spoken by Sydney Carton as he approaches the guillotine, it turns a last act into a judgment on the life that came before it—and becomes the line Trond pauses over during a solitary winter night.
The phrase in its scene
At two in the morning, while snow and high wind surround his isolated home, Trond reads the ending of Dickens’s novel by a small lamp. Carton sees the guillotine working and the women in the stalls counting as the executions proceed. He says farewell to the woman before him, imagining a land without time or sorrow, and then declares: “It is a far, far better thing that I do, than I have ever done . . .” The phrase’s comparison reaches backward across his life even as Carton’s life is ending: the deed he is performing now is set apart from everything he has done before.
Trond’s response
Trond remarks that, in Carton’s situation, it is not easy to disagree with him. The response acknowledges the force of Carton’s claim without spelling out a broader lesson; the phrase remains anchored to the immediate circumstance of a person facing death and measuring his present action against his past. Trond then calls the book entertaining, a dryly matter-of-fact reaction beside the solemn scene he has just read.
Placement and contrast
The passage moves from the novel’s extreme finality back into the small routines of Trond’s night. He smiles to himself, returns the book to its place among Dickens’s works, finishes his dram, turns off the kitchen light, and goes to bed. The starkness of Carton’s last words is neither explained away nor sustained as a grand pronouncement: it is followed by ordinary gestures and sleep. By morning, a tractor and snowplough are clearing the road toward Trond’s house, bringing the outside world back into the scene after the night spent reading.